Cardigan or Shirt?

I was perusing the J.Crew Factory website and saw this cute ensemble with a cardigan as a shirt.... and thought, "Hey I can do that!" So here was my attempt.  Not bad.

Cardigan: Stitch Fix (similar)
Skirt: Loft
Shoes: Banana Republic (similar)

Also, looking back at how I wore that shirt yesterday got me interested in doing the same with other clothes, so let's see how I wore this cardigan nearly two years ago, shall we?

Actually not bad, but the untucked shirt looks a bit frumpy.  This post actually reminds me I love that striped top... maybe I will wear it tomorrow, in fact...tucked in a bit, obvs.